Texas Insurance Agent Fraud Leads to $300K Premium Theft (2025)
October 8, 2025 | JacobiJournal.com — Insurance agent fraud in Texas has led to the conviction of Carlyle Poindexter, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud after admitting to overcharging clients nearly $300,000 in premium payments. The fraudulent scheme, which spanned several years, involved collecting inflated premiums from policyholders and diverting the excess funds for personal use. Premium Theft Scheme Uncovered Federal investigators revealed that Poindexter, who operated under a now-defunct insurance firm, intentionally manipulated policy costs and billing records to inflate customer invoices — a clear example of insurance agent fraud. The scheme was uncovered after multiple clients reported inconsistent charges and missing refund checks. According to court documents, Poindexter used false representations and fraudulent payment accounts to disguise premium theft, funneling funds through a series of personal and business accounts. The Texas Department of Insurance Fraud Unit assisted federal authorities in tracing the misappropriated funds. Legal Consequences and Industry Impact Poindexter now faces a potential prison sentence of up to 20 years under federal wire fraud statutes, along with restitution to affected policyholders, following his involvement in insurance agent fraud. State regulators have also moved to revoke his insurance license permanently. Industry experts warn that premium diversion schemes—in which agents pocket premiums instead of forwarding them to insurers—remain one of the most damaging forms of insurance fraud, eroding public trust and raising compliance costs for legitimate agents. Enforcement Actions Signal Stronger Oversight Authorities emphasized that this case underscores the state’s increased vigilance against insurance fraud. “Texas regulators are sending a clear message—misusing client premiums will lead to federal prosecution,” said one enforcement official familiar with the investigation. The case serves as a reminder for consumers to verify agent licensing and check policy statements directly with insurers to ensure payments are properly credited. Read the full coverage here for detailed case information. FAQs: Texas Insurance Agent Fraud What is premium theft in insurance? Premium theft occurs when an agent collects premium payments from clients but fails to remit them to the insurance company, keeping the funds for personal gain. How can policyholders detect insurance fraud? Clients should review billing statements carefully, confirm policy numbers directly with the insurer, and report any suspicious discrepancies to the state insurance department. What penalties apply for insurance agent fraud in Texas? Convictions for wire or insurance fraud can lead to up to 20 years in prison, substantial fines, and restitution to victims. How can regulators prevent premium diversion schemes? Enhanced audits, electronic payment tracking, and real-time reporting tools can help regulators and insurers identify premium theft earlier and deter repeat offenses. Stay informed — subscribe to JacobiJournal.com for more verified updates on insurance and compensation fraud enforcement. 🔎 Read More from JacobiJournal.com: