March 14, 2025 | JacobiJournal.com — A California insurance rate hike gained provisional approval as Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara signed off on State Farm’s request for a 22% homeowners insurance increase. However, the approval remains conditional, as the company must justify the hike with supporting data during a public hearing scheduled for April 8.
State Farm’s Response to the Provisional Approval
In a statement, State Farm acknowledged the decision but emphasized the need for long-term stability in the California insurance market, noting that the California insurance rate hike was a difficult but necessary step. “While the provisional nature of today’s decision does not provide full certainty, it is a step in the right direction,” the company stated. State Farm also confirmed that it would implement the provisionally approved rate while continuing discussions with the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to establish a sustainable path forward.
The insurer reiterated its commitment to transparency, stating, “State Farm General has worked openly and honestly with all parties involved. We will continue monitoring capacity to support risks and build sufficient capital for the future.”
Commissioner Lara’s Conditions for Approval
Lara has also urged State Farm to halt non-renewals and seek a $500 million capital infusion. He warned that without addressing these financial issues, the California insurance rate hike could fail to deliver meaningful relief for policyholders.
If upheld, the rate hikes would take effect on June 1, with increases including:
- 22% for homeowners
- 15% for renters
- 15% for condominium owners
- 38% for rental dwelling policies
State Farm stopped writing new policies in California in May 2023 and has already non-renewed thousands of existing policies.
The Financial Justification for Rate Hikes
Earlier this year, Lara had postponed approving the rate hike, instead calling a meeting with the company to obtain more details about its financial situation. At the time, State Farm cited significant underwriting losses as the primary reason for the requested increase. The company reported that for every $1 collected in premium, it has spent $1.26, leading to cumulative underwriting losses of over $5 billion in the past nine years.
State Farm cited significant underwriting losses as the primary reason for the California insurance rate hike, pointing to billions in wildfire-related claims and ongoing payout pressures. As of February 14, the company reported 11,400 home and auto claims related to the fires, with payouts exceeding $1.35 billion. Insurers across California have already paid more than $12 billion for losses from the state’s two largest January wildfires, which destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
“To resolve this matter, I am ordering State Farm to respond to questions in an official hearing, promoting transparency and a path forward,” Lara stated. “It is evident that other California insurers cannot absorb State Farm’s existing customers, which increases the risk of policyholders being forced onto the FAIR Plan, something we all want to avoid as we implement my Sustainable Insurance Strategy.”
Consumer Watchdog’s Opposition to Insurance Rate Hike
Consumer Watchdog, a consumer advocacy group, has opposed the emergency rate hike request since its submission. The group welcomed the public hearing, emphasizing that State Farm must provide clear evidence to justify the increase.
“The commissioner called a hearing, just as Consumer Watchdog has been urging since State Farm made its unprecedented $900 million ‘emergency’ rate hike request,” the organization stated. “It’s a victory for consumers that State Farm must make its case before a judge. So far, the company has failed to back up its request, and unless they provide compelling proof, the outcome should be a rejection.”
The Future of California’s Insurance Market
As the state’s largest homeowners insurer, State Farm’s future actions will have broad implications for policyholders. If the rate increase stands, the company may continue operating in California. However, if denied, more non-renewals could follow, adding to the state’s ongoing insurance crisis.
For more details on active insurance rate filings and consumer protections, visit the California Department of Insurance.
FAQs: About the California Insurance Rate Hike
What is the reason behind the insurance rate hike?
State Farm cited billions in underwriting losses and wildfire-related claims as the primary drivers of its proposed increase.
When will State Farm’s approved insurance rate hike take effect in California?
If upheld, the rate hike would take effect on June 1, 2025, impacting homeowners, renters, and condominium policyholders.
How does Commissioner Lara’s conditional approval affect policyholders?
The conditional approval requires State Farm to justify the hike in a public hearing while halting non-renewals and seeking added financial capital.
What role does Consumer Watchdog play in the California insurance rate hike process?
Consumer Watchdog opposes the increase, pushing for transparency and requiring State Farm to present strong evidence at the upcoming public hearing.
Stay informed on regulatory updates, insurance market shifts, and fraud investigations — subscribe today at JacobiJournal.com for breaking coverage.