Former Westminster police officer charged with workers’ compensation fraud after being spotted partying and traveling during medical leave. Tracey Leong reports for NBC4 News at 11 p.m., May 20, 2025. Credit: NBC Los Angeles — https://www.nbclosangeles.com/
May 21, 2025 | JacobiJournal.com – A former Westminster police officer faces felony charges for allegedly committing insurance fraud and workers’ compensation fraud during her disability leave, the Orange County District Attorney’s Office announced.
Nicole Brown, 39, from Riverside, faces nine felony counts for making false statements to receive compensation. She also faces six counts of fraudulent insurance claims. Prosecutors added a sentencing enhancement for aggravated white-collar crime involving over $100,000.
Her stepfather, attorney Peter Gregory Schuman, 57, from Buena Park, also faces felony charges for filing fraudulent insurance claims and conspiring to commit illegal acts.
Injury and Disability Insurance Fraud Allegations
Brown injured her forehead while arresting a suspect in March 2022. An emergency room doctor treated her and cleared her to return to work. However, she later claimed a severe concussion and went on temporary disability leave, which is now at the center of the insurance fraud investigation initiated by the Orange County District Attorney’s Office.
Evidence of Contradictory Activities
During this time, Brown reportedly attended the Stagecoach Music Festival in April 2023 and was seen traveling and partying. Witnesses reported her dancing and drinking, contradicting her claims of severe symptoms.
Investigators also found that Brown took part in two 5K races, snowboarded, skied, attended several soccer conferences, went to baseball games, played golf, and visited Disneyland. She also enrolled in online courses, despite complaining about screen sensitivity.
Defense Statement
Brown’s lawyer, Brian Gurwitz, said, “Ms. Brown suffered a debilitating head injury while on duty. She plans to vigorously challenge these allegations.”
Legal Consequences and Next Steps
The charges highlight increased scrutiny of workers’ compensation claims when claimants’ activities conflict with their reported injuries. Brown and Schuman face serious legal consequences if convicted.
Stay updated with local crime and legal news from Orange County.
FAQs: About Insurance Fraud and Disability Leave Abuse
What qualifies as insurance fraud during disability leave?
Insurance fraud occurs when an individual knowingly provides false or misleading information to receive disability benefits. In law enforcement or public service, this often includes exaggerating injuries or continuing to claim benefits after recovery.
How do investigators detect insurance fraud in disability leave cases?
Insurance fraud investigators often rely on surveillance footage, social media activity, medical record reviews, and witness testimony to identify discrepancies between a claimant’s reported injuries and actual behavior. In disability fraud cases, evidence of physical activity—like traveling or partying—while on leave can trigger prosecution.
What are the legal consequences of committing insurance fraud while on leave?
Penalties for insurance fraud may include felony charges, restitution orders, termination of employment, and loss of future benefits. In California, convicted individuals may also face imprisonment, fines, and professional disqualification.
Subscribe to JacobiJournal.com for trusted updates on law enforcement misconduct, insurance fraud cases, and public integrity prosecutions across the U.S.