Jacobi Journal of Insurance Investigation

Unveiling the truth behind insurance claims.
Protecting integrity in every investigation.

February 12, 2025 | JacobiJournal.com — Forgery and Identity Theft: Authorities have charged a North Carolina insurance agent with forgery and identity theft in what investigators describe as a case of insurance fraud, accusing him of fraudulently obtaining a life insurance policy and later attempting to claim benefits. Matthew Jackson Swift, 42, of Mount Airy, is now awaiting a court appearance scheduled for February 19.

Insurance fraud is a growing concern in North Carolina and across the United States, costing consumers and companies billions of dollars each year. According to the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud, scams like forged applications, staged claims, and false identities contribute to higher premiums for honest policyholders. State regulators note that cases involving licensed agents are especially troubling, since they undermine trust in an industry meant to provide financial protection for families and businesses.

Details of the Allegations

According to the North Carolina Department of Insurance (DOI), Swift forged documents twice in late 2023 to secure a life insurance policy from Southern Farm Bureau Life Insurance Co. Investigators revealed that the policyholder had no knowledge of the transaction. Shortly after, Swift allegedly submitted claims against the fraudulent policy, aiming to collect payouts unlawfully.

Law enforcement officers arrested Swift earlier this month. However, he posted a $75,000 bond and was released shortly after. His upcoming court hearing will determine the next steps in the case.

Swift’s Insurance Background and Previous Arrest

Records from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) indicate that Swift holds a valid insurance producer license in North Carolina. However, his broker license expired in 2023. Despite this, he remains authorized to sell life, health, property, and casualty insurance. In the past, he worked with both Progressive Southeastern Insurance and Southern Farm Bureau Life.

Notably, this is not the first time Swift has faced similar allegations in. Four months ago, authorities arrested him on related charges. In response, he denied any wrongdoing, claiming his former spouse had fabricated the accusations.

Ongoing Investigation and Consumer Protection Efforts

As the investigation continues, officials emphasize the importance of cracking down on insurance fraud to protect policyholders. The North Carolina DOI remains committed to holding fraudulent agents accountable and ensuring the integrity of the insurance industry.

Insurance fraud not only impacts companies and regulators but also drives up costs for everyday consumers who rely on honest coverage. Authorities stress that even a single act of fraud can erode public trust in the system, making it harder for families and businesses to feel secure. By aggressively pursuing cases like this one, state officials aim to send a strong message that deceptive practices will not be tolerated in North Carolina’s insurance market.

Read the official statement from the North Carolina Department of Insurance.


FAQs: North Carolina Insurance Agent Fraud Case

What are the specific charges against the North Carolina insurance agent forgery case?

He faces allegations of forging documents to secure a fraudulent life insurance policy and attempting to claim benefits without the policyholder’s knowledge.

Was this insurance agent accused of similar charges before?

Yes, this is not his first arrest. Authorities previously charged him with similar allegations just four months earlier.

What happens next in this insurance fraud case?

He is scheduled to appear in court on February 19, where the next steps in the legal process will be determined.

How does the state protect consumers from cases like this?

The North Carolina Department of Insurance actively investigates insurance fraud and enforces strict actions against agents who violate consumer trust.


Stay informed on breaking news and fraud investigations. Subscribe to JacobiJournal.com today for trusted updates.

🔎 Read More from JacobiJournal.com:

Leave a Reply