Skip to main content

Jacobi Journal of Insurance Investigation

CA Delivery Company Owners Fined $2M for Workers’ Comp Fraud

CA Delivery Company Owners Fined $2M for Workers’ Comp Fraud

April 4, 2025 | JacobiJournal.com — CA Delivery Company Owners: A Los Angeles couple received sentences after an investigation uncovered that they underreported $21 million in payroll for their delivery companies. Authorities say the scheme lasted several years and gave them an unfair advantage over competitors by cutting down on required workers’ compensation insurance premiums.

The fraud not only reduced their business costs but also put employees at risk by leaving them without proper coverage in the event of a workplace injury. According to investigators, this type of underreporting shifts the financial burden to insurers and the state, while undermining companies that comply with the law. The case against the delivery company owners highlights how payroll fraud can ripple through the entire workers’ compensation system, affecting honest employers, employees, and ultimately taxpayers.

Uninsured Companies and Fraudulent Claims

John Nemandoust (70) and Annette Assil (62) were sentenced for committing workers’ comp fraud. Nemandoust received 60 days in county jail, and Assil got 30 days. They also received 10 years of felony probation and must pay $2.2 million in restitution for unpaid premiums. CA Delivery Company Owners

The California Department of Insurance (CDI) began the investigation after reports indicated that two of the couple’s companies, Prompt Delivery and Affordable Messenger, had no insurance. Between 2013 and 2017, the couple only maintained workers’ comp insurance for A-1 Valley Services, their third company.

Underreported Payroll and Fraudulent Claims

Investigators found that when employees from the uninsured companies suffered work-related injuries, the couple submitted fraudulent claims under A-1 Valley Services’s policy. Over the four years, the couple filed claims for at least 20 employees from the uninsured companies.

A forensic audit showed that the companies reported only $1.4 million in payroll to their insurance carrier, though their actual payroll exceeded $25 million. This underreporting allowed the couple to evade $3 million in workers’ comp premiums.

Prosecution and Legal Consequences

The Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office prosecuted the case, emphasizing the seriousness of workers’ compensation fraud and its impact on both employees and the broader business community. Prosecutors argued that the scheme carried out by the delivery company owners was not just about unpaid premiums, but about creating an uneven playing field that disadvantaged legitimate businesses that follow state labor laws.

As part of the sentencing, the court stressed that felony probation and restitution payments serve as a warning to other employers who might consider similar fraudulent practices. Legal experts note that California continues to prioritize these types of prosecutions, as workers’ comp fraud undermines the integrity of the insurance system and can leave injured employees without the benefits they are entitled to.

This case stands as an example of how state authorities are working in collaboration with the California Department of Insurance to hold business owners accountable, ensuring that fraud does not go unpunished.

For more detailed guidance on workers’ compensation insurance compliance and fraud prevention, visit the California Department of Insurance official resource: California Department of Insurance – Workers’ Compensation Fraud.

New Update: California Delivery Company Owners’ $2.2 Million Restitution Order Highlights Workers Compensation Premium Fraud

The California delivery company owners convicted of workers compensation insurance fraud remain a significant example of how deliberate payroll underreporting and improper insurance claims can result in substantial criminal penalties. In April 2025, authorities reported that Los Angeles business owners John Nemandoust and Annette Assil had been sentenced following an investigation involving millions of dollars in unreported payroll.

The investigation focused on three delivery businesses operated by the couple: Prompt Delivery, Affordable Messenger, and A-1 Valley Services. According to the California Department of Insurance, the owners maintained workers compensation insurance for A-1 Valley Services while operating the other businesses without the required coverage.

Investigators determined that the delivery company owners misrepresented payroll information submitted to their insurance carrier, substantially reducing the premiums associated with their business operations.

A forensic audit revealed that the companies had reported approximately $1.4 million in payroll despite actual payroll exceeding $25 million during the period examined.

The discrepancy demonstrated the scale of the inaccurate financial reporting and raised concerns about whether the businesses had deliberately avoided workers compensation insurance obligations.

Authorities estimated that the scheme resulted in approximately $3 million in unpaid insurance premiums. These avoided premiums represented financial losses associated with the inaccurate reporting rather than a separate amount automatically recovered through sentencing.

The California delivery company owners were also found to have submitted workers compensation claims under the insured company’s policy for employees working at the uninsured businesses.

Investigators identified at least 20 employees whose workplace injury claims had allegedly been submitted through A-1 Valley Services despite their employment with the other companies.

This practice created additional concerns about the accuracy of insurance records and the proper identification of employers responsible for workplace injuries.

The California Department of Insurance investigated the activities, and the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office prosecuted the criminal case.

Following the prosecution, Nemandoust received a 60-day county jail sentence, while Assil received a 30-day county jail sentence.

Both defendants were also sentenced to 10 years of felony probation and ordered to pay approximately $2.2 million in restitution.

The restitution order was intended to address financial losses associated with the fraudulent insurance practices. However, the amount ordered by the court should not be confused with the amount actually collected from the defendants.

The California delivery company owners’ case illustrates how payroll fraud can affect the financial integrity of workers compensation insurance systems.

Insurance premiums are generally calculated using reported payroll, employee classifications, and other factors associated with workplace injury exposure.

When employers intentionally conceal wages or operate uninsured businesses, they may obtain an unfair financial advantage over competitors that accurately report payroll and maintain required coverage.

The case also demonstrates the importance of identifying the correct employer when reporting workplace injuries. Insurance claims submitted under an unrelated or improperly identified business can create complications for insurers, employers, and injured workers.

However, inaccurate employer reporting does not automatically eliminate an injured employee’s rights under California workers compensation law. Coverage and benefit eligibility depend on the applicable legal circumstances.

As of October 2026, the previously reported jail sentences, felony probation terms, and $2.2 million restitution order remain the established outcomes discussed in this update. Any subsequent modification of the sentences, restitution collection, or probation status has not been independently confirmed here.

The investigation reinforces the importance of maintaining accurate payroll records, ensuring that every business entity carries legally required insurance, and verifying that workplace injury claims identify the appropriate employer.

For California businesses, the prosecution demonstrates that workers compensation premium fraud can create consequences extending beyond unpaid premiums, including criminal convictions, restitution obligations, and reputational damage.

The continuing significance of the California delivery company owners’ fraud case lies in its demonstration of how payroll concealment and improper claims reporting can undermine insurance accountability while exposing employers to substantial legal and financial penalties.

For additional information, review the California Department of Insurance’s official resources concerning workers compensation insurance fraud, employer compliance, and enforcement investigations.


FAQs: CA Delivery Company Owners Workers’ Comp Fraud

Why were the CA Delivery company owners fined $2.2 million?

They were ordered to pay restitution after underreporting $21 million in payroll, which allowed them to avoid nearly $3 million in workers’ comp insurance premiums.

How did investigators uncover the fraud by the CA delivery company owners?

A forensic audit and insurance review revealed a significant payroll gap, along with fraudulent claims filed under their insured company, A-1 Valley Services.

What companies were involved in the case?

The couple operated Prompt Delivery, Affordable Messenger, and A-1 Valley Services. Only A-1 was insured, yet claims from the other two companies were falsely filed under it.

What legal consequences did the delivery company owners face?

They received county jail sentences, felony probation, and were ordered to repay $2.2 million in restitution for their fraudulent scheme.


Stay informed on the latest insurance fraud prosecutions, workers’ comp fraud cases, and public integrity updates. Subscribe to JacobiJournal.com today for expert reporting delivered directly to your inbox.

🔎 Read More from JacobiJournal.com: