May 02, 2025 | JacobiJournal.com — Workers compensation commute rule was at the center of a recent California appellate decision involving a disputed carpool exception. On May 2, 2025, JacobiJournal.com reported that the court reaffirmed the long-standing “going-and-coming rule,” holding that an employee injured while carpooling in a privately arranged ride with a co-worker was not entitled to employer liability coverage—even though the co-worker received a small travel stipend from the employer.
Background: The Going-and-Coming Rule
Under California workers’ compensation and liability law, the workers compensation commute rule—also known as the going-and-coming rule—generally exempts employers from liability for employee injuries or torts that occur during the employee’s commute to and from work. Exceptions to this rule exist, particularly when the commute is considered part of the scope of employment or when the employer receives a direct benefit from providing or arranging transportation.
Case Details
The case involved an employee who was injured in a car accident while carpooling with a co-worker. The co-worker had coordinated the carpool arrangement informally and received a modest stipend from the employer intended to encourage carpooling and reduce parking congestion.
In its analysis, the court reviewed whether this situation could qualify as an exception under the workers compensation commute rule, which determines when an employer can be held liable for commute-related injuries. Ultimately, the court found that the stipend did not transform the co-worker into an agent of the employer, nor did it constitute sufficient employer control to make the carpool trip fall within the course of employment.
The ruling emphasized that the workers compensation commute rule continues to exclude most voluntary carpools from coverage, even when small incentives are provided, unless the employer directly mandates or manages the transportation arrangement.
Court’s Reasoning
Court Rejects Carpool Exception, The panel emphasized that the employer neither mandated the carpool nor exercised control over the transportation. Therefore, the injury sustained during the commute remained outside the scope of employment. The court declined to extend liability under the exception to the going-and-coming rule, noting that doing so would significantly blur the boundary between personal and work-related travel.
This decision reaffirms longstanding precedent that voluntary carpools typically do not qualify for exceptions to the going-and-coming rule—even when small employer incentives are involved.
New Update: California WCAB Revisits Going-and-Coming Rule After Court of Appeal Remand
The California workers’ compensation dispute involving Javier Hernandez and a fatal 2022 vanpool accident developed further after the Third District Court of Appeal issued its May 1, 2025 decision in Zenith Insurance Co. v. Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board. Although the appellate court rejected the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board’s application of the special risk and dual purpose exceptions, subsequent proceedings produced a separate finding that the insurer had not established that the going-and-coming rule barred Hernandez’s claim.
The underlying accident occurred on May 26, 2022, while Hernandez and other agricultural workers were traveling home from a jobsite in Winters. Their van overturned during the commute, killing the driver and three passengers and injuring the remaining occupants. Hernandez sustained severe injuries, including the amputation of his right leg. He worked for Ceja Reyes, Inc., a farm labor contractor, and the company was insured for workers’ compensation by Zenith Insurance Company.
The Court of Appeal examined whether the original WCAB decision correctly applied two exceptions to the going-and-coming rule. The court concluded that neither the special risk exception nor the dual purpose exception applied to the facts established in the record. It emphasized that Ceja Reyes did not provide or arrange the transportation, and the vanpool had been independently organized by another employee as a personal business. Hernandez paid $10 per day to use the van. This payment was not an employer-provided travel stipend, an important distinction when evaluating the employer’s involvement in the transportation arrangement.
The appellate court annulled the WCAB’s May 29, 2024 order and remanded the matter for further proceedings. Its May 1, 2025 opinion clarified that the special risk exception generally concerns risks connected to the employer’s premises or conditions over which the employer exercises control. The dual purpose exception also requires an incidental employer benefit beyond the ordinary need for employees to travel to work. The court found that the evidence did not satisfy either exception.
However, the litigation did not end with the appellate ruling. On March 13, 2026, the WCAB issued a Notice of Intention to Issue an Opinion and Decision After Remittitur in case ADJ16567838. After reviewing the record, the Board identified another basis for addressing the commute issue: Hernandez’s travel did not constitute a local commute to a fixed workplace at fixed hours.
The Board noted that Hernandez traveled approximately 60 miles between Yuba City and Winters, with commute times exceeding an hour in each direction. His daily starting and ending times also varied. The Board further questioned the reliability of employer payroll records submitted to support the insurer’s position, finding discrepancies between the records and evidence concerning the workers’ schedules after the accident.
Based on this review, the WCAB proposed substituting findings that Zenith had failed to meet its burden of proving that the workers compensation commute rule, also known as the going-and-coming rule, barred recovery. The Board also stated that all other issues were deferred. The March 13 document was a notice of intention, not confirmation that every disputed issue had received a final determination. The Board rescinded the scheduled March 17, 2026 trial setting and allowed the parties an opportunity to object before issuing its intended decision.
As of October 2026, the available official record reviewed for this update does not establish the final resolution of all remaining issues or the ultimate benefits determination. The distinction between the appellate court’s rejection of two exceptions and the WCAB’s subsequent analysis of whether the rule applied in the first place is central to understanding the case.
For employers, insurers, claims administrators, and injured workers, the proceedings demonstrate that California’s going-and-coming rule requires a fact-specific assessment. Commute distance, work schedules, transportation arrangements, employer control, and the reliability of employment records can all influence the analysis. The case also illustrates why an appellate ruling on particular exceptions should not automatically be treated as a final determination of every issue affecting compensability.
FAQs: About the Workers Compensation Commute Rule
What is the workers compensation commute rule?
The workers compensation commute rule limits employer liability for injuries sustained during an employee’s normal commute.
Are carpools covered under the workers compensation commute rule?
Generally, voluntary carpools are not covered unless they are required or directly controlled by the employer.
Why does the workers compensation commute rule matter?
It sets clear boundaries between personal travel and work duties, helping define when injuries are work-related.
Can employer-provided stipends affect the workers compensation commute rule?
In most cases, small employer-provided travel stipends do not override the workers compensation commute rule. Unless the employer exerts significant control over the transportation or makes it a work requirement, commute-related injuries typically remain outside the scope of workers’ compensation coverage.
How does the workers compensation commute rule apply to remote or hybrid employees?
For remote or hybrid employees, the workers compensation commute rule usually applies only to travel between home and the employer’s physical workplace. Trips made purely for personal reasons are not covered, but if travel is required for a specific work assignment, different rules may apply.
Want to stay ahead of legal developments in employment and workers’ compensation? Visit JacobiJournal.com for detailed case law analysis, fraud updates, and court rulings that matter to legal, insurance, and HR professionals.
🔎 Read More from JacobiJournal.com:
- San Joaquin County DA Secures Felony Conviction in Workers’ Comp Fraud Case
- Fired State Employees Exposed Personal Data of 33K Texans
- Investigators Tie Trio to $2.4 Million in Losses Across Southern New England
- Heritage Sues Adjuster for Libel Over ’60 Minutes’ Report
- Cargo Theft Surges in 2024, Led by California, Texas, and Florida





